Photographs by PR Photos

Long before Chord Overstreet joined the cast of Glee as Sam Evans and Brant Daugherty appeared on ABC Family’s hit show Pretty Little Liars as Noel Kahn, they starred together in a web series called Private, based on the best-selling novels by Kate Brian. Chord played the leading man as Josh Hollis, while Brant played murder victim Thomas Pearson–a part that limited his role to the first few episodes.

It’s sort of crazy when you think about it. PRIVATE fans discovered Chord first, way back in 2009–before Taylor Swift even knew he existed! And now he’s singing and dancing alongside Lea Michele, and Brant is hanging around with Lucy Hale and company. Some PLL fans even think Brant’s character may be A!

Have you been following Chord and Brant’s post-PRIVATE careers? Tell us what you think!